Republican State Senate hopeful David Storobin sent out a press release today accusing Democratic opponent Councilman Lew Fidler of “ducking” debates in the Orthodox Jewish community. Fidler’s campaign, though, said no such invitations were ever extended.

Storobin’s release claims Fidler refused debate invitations from two prominent Jewish groups: Agudath Israel and the Council of Jewish Organizations of Flatbush. He claims the councilman is “ducking” the debate, though he has no “problem trolling for votes” in the Orthodox community.

The councilman has agreed to two debates already, one of which he says is sponsored by the League of Women Voters (though, actually, it’s sponsored by the Canarsie Courier) and another by the Manhattan Beach Civic Association.

“Councilman Fidler is turning his back on the Orthodox Community. He’s playing favorites by agreeing to one debate and not another. This is not what the people of the 27th District are looking for in a state senator.”

According to Fidler’s team though, Storobin’s got it all wrong. They say there was no such invitation from either organization.

However, the councilman is being forced to take a step back from the campaign trail by health issues. Before Storobin’s release was sent, Fidler sent out the following statement today:

A few days ago I was admitted to the hospital with a severe allergic reaction to a prescription medication I take to treat Gout.  My physician has instructed me to be off my feet for the next few days.  I’m grateful to my constituents, staff and the wonderful volunteers who continue to spend day and night pounding the pavement for our campaign.  As soon as I have the permission of my physicians – and my wife – I intend to return full steam to the campaign trail.  Of course, my district office will continue actively handling the day-to-day needs of my constituents.

It does not appear, however, that the health concerns will cause a cancellation of any of the scheduled debates.

Sheepshead Bites has contacted Agudeth Israel and the Council of Jewish Organizations of Flatbush to confirm whether or not an invitation had been sent to Fidler. However, our calls went unanswered, likely because of the Sabbath.

UPDATE: We just received this update from Kalman Yeger of Councilman Fidler’s office….

David Storobin continues to drag this campaign to the gutter with lies and deceit, this time inventing an imaginary debate.  The fact is that Councilman Fidler agreed to every single debate offered in this campaign.  Mr. Storobin obviously invented this imaginary event, to which we were never invited.  If Mr. Storobin had any class, he would have offered traditional ‘refuah sh’laimah’ (‘full recovery’) wishes, instead of launching another lie-filled attack.

And from David Simpson in Mr. Storobin’s office…

 I understand that the Fidler camp is denying there was an invitation to debate. Keeping in mind that invitations don’t always come in an embossed envelope, let me say this for the record.

Rabbi Shmuel Lefkowitz who is with the Council of Jewish Organizations invited us to debate sponsored by that organization and Agudath Israel. We agreed, and it was our understanding that Fidler’s camp also agreed. After that, emails and phone calls went back and forth trying to firm up a date and logistics. Then, this afternoon (Friday), Lefkowitz got back to us and said Fidler had pulled out.

I will make every effort to get you in touch with representatives from the Council of Jewish Organizations to back up our claim, but it’s probably not going to happen until later in the weekend. I have made several phone calls and no one is answering because Shabbos has already begun.

That said, Fidler’s response skirts the issue. He’s deflecting onto whether or not a “formal” invitation exists instead of saying whether or not he agrees to an Orhtodox debate. Does he or doesn’t he? We were told he said no and we’re sticking by that.

For our part, we are still committed to doing this debate. If Fidler is waiting for a formal invitation (whatever that is), he should first tell the organizations who are trying to host it that he is willing to debate, as Storobin has. Then we can send formal invitations to everyone.

We’ll let you know more as this develops.

Related posts

  • Pingback: Roundup: Cuomo Speaks; Evaluations Released; Redistricting Wrangle | Politicker

  • Jim

    Fidler is obviously the one playing dirty politics here. Why would a candidate make up a story about a debate and name the organizations wanting to arrange the debate? The accuracy of the debate can be verified by the organizations involved and that candidates integrity would be put on the line. Why would a candidate put their integrity on the line for a stupid attack?

    Anyone that can explain this?

    • levp

      Yes, it can be verified, but not earlier than tomorrow (Sunday).  So how about we hold the accusations until then?

    • http://www.flickr.com/photos/lisanne001 Lisanne!

       Stupid attacks aren’t so stupid if they sound plausible. Plausable doesn’t mean true.

  • bagels

    I see Moe and Larry, but where’s Curly?

  • http://twitter.com/Lostinservice Lostinservice

    I hope to hear more about this, but Fidler’s defense seems plausible since this is entirely in line with Strobin’s tactic of aligning himself with orthodox Jewish voters while simultaneously displacing Fidler from them. Again, why is this campaign being run as if there’s an election of a head rabbi and not a State Senator?

  • Meallad

    I am so tired of this campaign. Its so dirty I want to throw up.  I knew I was going to vote against Storobin because of his dirty tactics and lies to the russian community on the russian tv, but Fidler has stopped impressing me. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Gene-Berardelli/1173482469 Gene Berardelli

    Lew ducking debates?  This sounds oddly familiar… :-)

    • http://www.flickr.com/photos/lisanne001 Lisanne!

      Some advice. I’d lay back a bit right now. Being too quick to judge and not being in possession of the facts can make one look partisan and lacking in credibility. Storobin’s a fish you’d be wise to throw back into the water. He’s just not the prize catch that you want to show the voters.

      • http://twitter.com/Lostinservice Lostinservice

        He is partisan, he challenged Fidler in 2009 as the GOP nominee for City council in district 46.

        http://elections.nytimes.com/2009/nyc/city-council/46

        • http://www.flickr.com/photos/lisanne001 Lisanne!

          Yes, I remember that campaign well. Sheepshead Bites gave it more than fair coverage.

          • http://www.facebook.com/people/Gene-Berardelli/1173482469 Gene Berardelli

            Yes, it did.  And it took Ned a whole lot of time and energy to organize a debate that the Councilman was VERY resistant to doing.  Hence, the quip. 

          • http://www.flickr.com/photos/lisanne001 Lisanne!

            He did the debate. Additionally a 3rd party candidate was included as well.

            There were conditions, in part because Sheepshead Bites was little more than a year old and Fidler wanted a properly organized debate. When the conditions were met the debate took place.

            This would not be an unusual occurrence. Quite often there is difficulty finding agreement on rules, venue, and even the seating arrangement. Additionally, Fidler did not need the debate. He was the incumbent in a heavily Democratic district. Not participating would not have adversely affected his candidacy. He choice was a recognition of how voters deserve an opportunity to hear the views of ALL the candidates. Because that is how democracy works.

          • http://www.facebook.com/people/Gene-Berardelli/1173482469 Gene Berardelli

            That’s a little revisionist history.  Let’s not make stuff up. 

            I had to dog him for weeks to do the debate – and only then, he only agreed to do it where there was NO audience allowed.  Ask Ned about all the hoops he had to jump through, from date, to time, to moderator (who actually endorsed Fidler on camera prior to the debate!), and even then, he debated begrudgingly. 

  • Pingback: Jewish Leaders Contradict Storobin Campaign About Debate Folly | Sheepshead Bay News Blog