The owner attempts to get the dog back from an Animal Care & Control worker.

Authorities raided two Sheepshead Bay homes owned by one couple, leading to the rescue of 23 dogs living in deplorable conditions.

Officials from a slew of agencies – including Animal Care & Control, the Brooklyn District Attorney’s office, FDNY, NYPD, Department of Buildings and Department of Health – descended first on 2713 Avenue Y this morning with a warrant, eventually bursting into the house to find clutter, garbage and 10 poorly cared for Shetland Sheepdogs.

Afterwards, authorities moved on to the pet owners’ primary residence at 4215 Bedford Avenue, where they pulled out 13 more dogs – mostly Shetlands.

According to a volunteer organization involved in the case, the dogs were underfed, anemic and flea-infested. They had also never seen a veterinarian to receive vaccinations or checkups.

The owners are being charged with at least 20 counts of cruelty to animals, according to a representative from the DA’s attorney on the scene. (CORRECTION [2/17/2012]: The DA has not yet filed charges against the couple.)

They were also given fines for various violations related to health and safety matters.

Neighbors of the Avenue Y house, which appeared to be in worse condition, told Sheepshead Bites that the couple has been hoarding the canines for approximately 20 years. However, the couple does not actually live in the Avenue Y house;  it has been occupied solely by the shelties.

“They only ever go in at night,” said a neighbor. “She shows up with a big bag of dog food and feeds them.”

The house does not have gas or running water, neighbors alleged.

The immediate next door neighbor told Sheepshead Bites that the couple have kept dogs there for as long as she can remember.

“I never had any problems with the people here, but it’s horrible they had so many dogs,” said Beana Manashvily, a neighbor. She said she’s grown so used to the barking that she never notices it anymore.

The ASPCA and ACC have made multiple visits to the property, neighbors said, sometimes taking some of the dogs away, but more often never gaining access to the house.

Manashvily also noted the unsanitary conditions, adding that the dogs were never allowed to use the large backyard. Occassionally, the wife would allow them run free in the driveway. Every garbage night, she said, the wife would take out 10 to 15 heavy duty bags full of garbage. Other neighbors complained of rat problems.

The filth and clutter at the Avenue Y home caused concern for the city responders. Firefighters took precautionary measures, such as accessing the roof to look down into the home for safety reasons. A Hazardous Materials Unit also responded.

“Ever seen the show Hoarders?” asked an on-scene rep for the DA when asked about the condition of the home. “That’s what it’s like. Hoarders.

The city has condemned the home and will be clearing it out over the next few days.

The investigation into the couple’s alleged animal abuse began at the urging of the Tri-State Shetland Sheepdog Rescue organization, a Long Island-based rescue service. According to one of the directors, Tim Makridakis, who was on scene this morning, the couple hit their radar several years ago when they rescued 21 abused shelties from another person. They found that this couple had given that man 10 dogs six years ago.

Makridakis then contacted the couple and befriended the wife. He visited multiple times, taking photos of the dog’s condition and, sometimes, convincing them to allow him to take some of the dogs to his shelter for adoption.

“I think they bred them to sell them, but then I think it became a hoarding type thing,” Makridakis said. He added that the dogs were mostly in-bred. “I showed them pictures of the [dogs we took] in their new homes, happy and healthy, but they wouldn’t let us take the rest. In their minds, they loved these dogs.”

Makridakis said he believed the dogs would all make quick and complete recoveries, as their neglect wasn’t as bad as he has seen in other cases.

“They’ll be in foster care for six months to a year,” he said. “With proper care and conditioning, they’ll be fine for adoption.”

The animals have been taken by Animal Care & Control, where they will be observed for a few days. Tri-State Shetland Sheepdog Rescue will then take custody of the dogs and put them in foster homes. Anyone interested in adopting the animals can contact the organization through their website.

This is a breaking news story and may contain inaccuracies. We will update it as more information becomes available. If anyone has more information or additional photos, please send them to tips (at) sheepsheadbites (dot) com.

This is the third version of this article.

Related posts

  • Scott

    FINALLY.  our complaints have materialized.  this couple is crazy.  i live a couple of doors over, and this has been occurring for the last 15 years.  He is a mental case, claiming to be wounded in vietnam, walking with a cane.  she   is vietnamese i believe, claiming to have met him in vietnam.  they have “bred” and subjected to cruelty, and, subsequently put down MANY collies during this time.  they live in filthy conditions just like dogs.

    • Anonymous

       :( 

    • geneee

      SNITCH BITCH

    • geneee

      rat

    • Anonymous

      Has anyone ever called the authorities on the homeowners before?  I couldn’t live there and not call and turn them in.

      • http://www.nedberke.com Ned Berke

        Several neighbors said they made calls. However, the city cannot obtain a warrant based on neighbors’ allegations, and I was told that most attempts to gain access to the house were unsuccessful. It takes time to build a case, and you need a case to obtain a warrant.

        Still… 20 freakin years…

        • http://www.njluxurymotors.com Arthur Borko

          I’ll bet 100$ that if they just had someone investigate the garbage, which you DONT need a warrant for, or had an officer observe the house at night for a week that they’d have enough to get a warrant. 

          The authorities could have acted if they gave a shit, but they didn’t. Not until they had the evidence staring them in the face I guess.

          • nolastname

            I spend half my time 1/2 block away from the Ave Y address and thought there were only 2 dogs in the residence. And I have an investigative personality. I wish I knew Pat was in such trouble, I don’t know if over the years I could have helped or changed anything for the better but I would feel less sad if I could have given an effort. 
            What I do wonder about is if there were agencies pre-involved (and I do not mean ACC,) that did not do their on site visits. 
            PS. the authorities that acted (I think) were called to the table way after the dinner bell rang.

        • Anonymous

          Yeah Ned, really, 20 years?  If neighbors were calling, I can’t believe it took so long to get things taken care of. 

  • Anonymous

    BARC is gonna get a buttload of dogs soon! LOL

    I’ll take that Pomeranian! 

  • Someone

    Do you know where they’re taking the dogs? 

    • Missy

      I am sure they will go to the ASPCA or ACC!!!

      • Chrissyy718

        Missy Will Be Getting A New Dog!!!! LOL

      • Anonymous

        How many are you going to bring home, Missy?  Hey Everyone – Missy  has 3 rescue dogs and they’re all sweeties!!

        • Chrissyy718

          Missy Is The Bestest If She could She would Bring them all Home!!!! I Love My Cuzzie!!!!

          • Anonymous

            I know she would.  I know that if she finds out where they are, she’ll try to find them homes. 

    • geneee

      the dogs are most likely loaded with worms and kennel cough not to mention inbred. they will be terminated. not to mention that they never got a parvo, distemper and corona shots. 

      • nolastname

        Termination is NOT where they are headed. They will be fine in a month, probably  sooner.

    • http://twitter.com/Yankee_Vik Vik

      At least ten of them (all 1 year-old Sheepdogs) are at Brooklyn ACC on a legal hold. If you know ACC, you know what that means… :/

      • nolastname

        Tell me what that means, please.

        • http://www.njluxurymotors.com Arthur Borko

          Maybe he’s implying that they’ll be put to sleep. I hope not. If they are relatively healthy they should be easy to find homes for. Such adorable puppies.

  • http://www.njluxurymotors.com Arthur Borko

    Que the jokes about the couple loosing their lunch in 5…4…3…2….

  • Georgia

    These people should get 20yrs for or never come out they do not deserve pets. This is so bad. They need to be put away and get help 

    • Anonymous

      20 years is not nearly enough time.  Animals need their humans to care for them, not just to drop off food occasionally.  The worst part is, people like this never think they have done the wrong thing. 

      • Georgia

        I agree they should lock them up & throw away the key we don’t need people like this around. And 20yrs is not enough time this is so terrible 

    • geneee

      20 years for a psych disorder? rapists and murderers dont even get that much time.

      • Georgia

        Well maybe they should & they will think twice.

    • Julio

      They fed the dogs, cleaned up their feces, and gave them a run.  Where is the animal cruelty here? 

      When I heard that one neighbor complained about rats, I knew that this is a sure sign of neighbor envy.  The collies would have killed the rats!

  • http://www.brucebrodinsky.com Bruce B

    Animal hoarding is an unpublicized problem, but more widespread than one would guess. Most times the accused thinks he’s a caring individual, but the reality is, the person needs help of an emotional nature. Threatening them will not work – it is a psychological disorder. The poor animals need to be saved, and the person needs to get help and we need to ensure a non- repeat.

    • nolastname

      Well said Bruce. It is a very sad situation for all involved. 
      The couple definitely did not think they were hurting the dogs nor themselves.

      • http://www.flickr.com/photos/lisanne001 Lisanne!

         It seems obvious from the photos that these people are crushed. These dogs were the center of their lives. Sad that some people don’t learn that you can’t save all the animals, there are responsible limits that ensure the safety and health of the ones you do rescue.

        • nolastname

          I am familiar with the couple. Though I took pictures I felt pain, restraint and compassion. There are so many what ifs, should haves and I wishes that it breaks my heart. 

          • http://www.flickr.com/photos/lisanne001 Lisanne!

            I’m sure that well meaning people have tried to explain to these people that they were in over their head. Sadly, short of taking drastic and direct action there was no way of controlling the situation. These people are not alone, in New York City alone there are hundreds of people doing the same thing. Some of them had their animals taken from them, but they start all over again. There are psychologists who  specialize in cases like this. But their clients still manage to believe their behavior is necessary, even though the result is obviously not beneficial to the animals they are trying to help.

          • nolastname

            It’s kinda like an empty nest syndrome. A combination of hoarding and empty nest. It truly pains the heart.

          • http://www.flickr.com/photos/lisanne001 Lisanne!

            A lot of people do start hoarding after their kids are grown. It guess it gives them a sense of purpose.

      • http://www.brucebrodinsky.com Bruce B

        As you might infer from my post, I have a vested interest in this issue, it’s of a personal nature to me.

  • http://www.njluxurymotors.com Arthur Borko

    I wonder how much it would cost to make that house livable again.

    • Anonymous

      You would probably have to gut the place completely, as animal stink (urine/feces) never goes away.  Not even scrubbing the carpets would help.  Plus the poor dogs were infested with fleas – you would definitely have to get rid of all rugs.  Its a shame that the dogs had to endure such horrible treatment.  I would never give these owners a penny for the house

    • geneee

      hit it and flip it

  • http://www.nedberke.com Ned Berke

    Also… got to give props to nolastname for tipping me off to the article, which is why we were able to beat the Daily News, the Post and News 12. Thanks nolastname!

    • nolastname

      I don’t know why I am so good to you. Thanks for the mention, does it come with a beer? You’re welcome.

  • Anonymous

    Feds came and took our Babies!!!!!!!!

  • Muckpe

    Beware the animal rescuer! Many Brooklynites unknowingly support the most hideous animal cruelty by giving money to so-called animal rescuers who on reality are the scum of the earth, pimping their animals for cash they spend on themselves. Remember Hearts and Homes? Total scam. Milked the people of Park Slope out of tens of thousands of dollars for decades till they were discovered and arrested. There is no oversight on animal rescue so the lowest of the low scam everyone. If you want to rescue an animal do it yourself.

    • nolastname

      So why don’t you be more specific instead of remember when’s? Are you going to foster any of these animals with all your talk? 
      Nooo, just put down all the animal rescues.
      Beware what you yourself unknowingly spew out of your mouth.
      Do you see all the city departments involved in this effort? Do you think it will be inhumanely dealt with at this point? 
      Did you not see Tod there? Did you not read the effort and time Makridakis put into this? Now STFU. TY

  • PRBOMBSHELLNY

    WOW THATS AROUND THE CORNER FROM ME,,, DAM. HOPE THOSE DOGS ARE OK AND FING A FOREVER HOME SOON

  • nolastname
  • Ghghg

    The ASPCA were repeatedly called over the years, and inspected the home. The last time they arrived they declared the environment to be fit and refused to remove the animals. They said they were being adequately cared for despite the fact that there was no heat, no running water and unsanitary conditions. Some of the animals had bite wounds and were aggressive given the environment in which they were raised. The ASPCA’s internal guidelines should be scrutinized and the handling of this case reviewed as well.

  • Pingback: DA: No Charges Filed Against Animal Hoarders… Yet | Sheepshead Bay News Blog

  • http://profiles.google.com/gotpups terry ward

    They were selling the dogs on the net.

    What else do you need to know?
    Good riddance.

  • Pingback: ASPCA Rescues 23 Dogs From Brooklyn Home With No Running Water (VIDEO) – Huffington Post « Abolish Pest Control Serving Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, New York

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1030392650 Angie Johnson

    im sorry but you can all say what you want but the dogs look in good condition well groomed nailes trimed and not dirty border collies are thin like that alot of times the news and agences will make up or exaggerate conditions to make it look justifiable

    i feel bad for this couple its mental illness and needed some help 

    • Bob Has2Dogs

      hello this is 4 months later 
      I live in Texas and we now have 2 of these dogs that came from this home  in Brooklyn. 
      the Owner had voluntarily  released about 10 dogs   a year and a half ago
       we got one  skinny female-16 months ago, she is now fat , happy and very bark yplaying constantly with our other 2 rescue  shelties.   and   co fostered the second one, and now have finally adopted the second one  we have some behavior problems  with both of them but they are getting better one has personally adopted me and sleeps right on my pillow at night , the other one has still some  fear issues, but will eat from my hand and climb-  into my lap to get treats. after 18 months sehe is starting to let me pet her  and brush hera little . both can now walk on leashes, but  had a hard time of it  adapting to a leash. the male will let me brush him and brush his teeth. he lets me carry him around the house. 
       the are getting better in every way, but it takes a lot of time, patience and love.  we had only one issue with parasites , but we did get them adopted thru Houston(tx) SHELTIE  rescue who were the ones who got  10 of them transported to texas 18 months ago. but we had been rooting for the final release of all of the other ones. 

  • Pingback: City Hauls Away Trash From Dog Hoarder’s House | Sheepshead Bay News Blog

  • Pingback: State Senator Marty Golden Sponsors Animal Cruelty Registry Bill | Bensonhurst News Blog

  • Pingback: Sheltie Dogs From Animal Hoarder Home Can Finally Be Adopted | Sheepshead Bay News Blog