• Grillin On The Bay - March 27, 2010

Simon Belsky, Candidate for City Council in Sheepshead Bay

Ms. Rosenthal sat next to Simon Belsky. She leaned over him, nodding, as he read. He spoke as if he was citing Chaucer or Whitman, or even Holy Gospel. All the while, his gruff voice booming, Mrs. Belsky buzzed about, serving drinks and assuring the comfort of her guests. Eventually she came to rest, sitting on the floor. And seeing this scene – a righteous man preaching, an elderly woman revering, and a wife adoring – I realized that I was not going to be writing your usual political profile.

All of that, of course, is absolute literary hyperbole; a writer’s mind twisting a perfectly normal scene. But that doesn’t negate the fact that Belsky is hardly your usual politician. He is, to say the least, rough around the edges. He has taken on causes that most politicians would call esoteric at best. He eschews the conventional political process. And his language… well, he’s more sailor than politician.

The 63-year-old retiree has become a bit of a prophet to the parking dispossessed. Take Rosenthal, for example. Just days before, Rosenthal – a Midwood resident with handicap privileges – had received a ticket for parking without paying a meter. The only problem is, she was nowhere near the address listed on the ticket, and there was no meter at her actual location. Angry at the fine, but like many other victims of incompetent parking regulators, she had little knowledge of how to fight it.

Belsky, though, had just been profiled in the NY Daily News – where Rosenthal got his number – for coming out victorious in a 2 ½ year battle versus the city. Outraged about a ticket he received for parking near a hydrant where there was none, he took the fight to the New York State Supreme Court, where the justices ruled the fines be dismissed and the city pay his court fees. The document he read to Rosenthal was the ruling in his case by Judge Michael Ambrosio – and he read it with fire in his voice.

Most people, his wife included, would have just paid the fine and avoided the hassle. But Belsky is a glutton for bureaucratic heckling. With one victory behind him, he’s stepping into the ring yet again, this time as a contender in the Democratic primaries against incumbent Councilman Michael C. Nelson, who represents the 48th District (Midwood, Sheepshead Bay, Manhattan Beach).

Like many folk frustrated with contemporary governance, Belsky has little love for the city’s politicians. In his narrative of New York politics, Bloomberg is a thief, the City Council his cronies, and almost every agent of governance an incompetent fraud, ridden with corruption and idiocy.

“This isn’t a government for the people,” he told Sheepshead Bites. “It’s a government that rapes the people.”

As his platform, Belsky speaks to that anger and disillusionment in all of us. He rails against corruption and mismanagement. He pleads for transparency. And he so cries for common sense that those talking to him – or at least I did – take a step back lest he swings his fist in frustration. This part, I promise, is no literary hyperbole.

Among the issues he focuses on are, of course, parking. As councilman he plans to work with the city’s prominent law schools to enlist students in a battle against abusive ticketing practices. The pro-bono organization will organize victims into a potential class-action lawsuit against the city, filing appeal after appeal until administrators act on the need for reform. He also plans to open the books of the city’s financial black holes – like the MTA and the School Construction Authority – and broadcast those agencies’ catastrophic financial bungling to the world.

“I will have the biggest voice you’ll ever see to address mismanagement, corruption and quality-of-life issues in this city,” he said.

In Sheepshead Bay, Belsky hopes to rekindle the fight for down-zoning and increased parking. He has already latched onto issues such as the Cherry Hill – Lundy’s debate, in which he skewers the likes of Councilman Nelson, CB 15 Chair Theresa Scavo and State Senator Carl Kruger, for opposing a business that has poured millions into a decrepit building. And he has singled out the fishing fleet as a valuable Brooklyn industry that needs to be promoted by city authorities.

But does he have a chance? Can a foul-mouthed, hot-tempered retiree, with no political experience win an election against a two-term incumbent? That’s up to the electorate – and if his fundraising is any indication, they’re reacting to his message. Belsky has already raised more than $13,000, primarily in small contributions from a spattering of housewives, retirees, small business owners and the self-employed. Not bad for a guy who says he “will not give funds to political groups to buy votes,” or pander to local political parties and interest groups for campaign funds.

But in the presence of Belsky, I had the feeling winning is a secondary objective. His real aim seems to be to leave a mark in the consciousness of the electorate; to inspire others to fight the Kafka-esque obsolescence of an idiotic political machine.

“Whether I win or lose doesn’t matter,” he said. “If I lose, my wife and I will go on a cruise. But I guarantee this, you’ll never see anything like me again.”

As for Ms. Rosenthal, she followed Belsky’s advice. Her ticket was dismissed a few days later.

(If you’ve been wrongly accused of a parking violation, you can contact Simon Belsky at 718-769-7406 or 917-335-2609, or by e-mailing him.)

  • Ray Johnson
    You think Mr. Belsky's language is like a sailor's? Ned, have you seen your post from yesterday?
    http://www.sheepsheadbites.com/2009/07/goodbye-...
  • Well Nelson is an ineffectual moron. Since I currently live in Midwood, i guess he's running in my district. He's got my vote!

    2 years ago my car got broken into overnight. Whomever did it left a lighter in the front seat. When I pointed this out to the officer as he took my police report he dismissed it. I had to ASK him to take the lighter as evidence and instead of putting on a plastic glove and putting in a small evidence bag he turned a glove inside out and folded it over the lighter before stuffing it in his pocket. He acted like it was a waste of his time filling out a report for a theft and vandalism. The guy basically made me feel like I was robbed all over again by his dismissive "don't give a shit" attitude. I understood stuff like this happens all the time, but the guy left tangible evidence. What if he's a repeat offender? What if it's part of a ring? They could have had a fingerprint right there but the guy just didn't care!

    That morning I emailed Mr Nelson (In fact that email is still in my gmail archives). If memory serves Nelson is on the committee that deals with civilian complaints about police. I never got a single reply to my email. Not one. Not an email, not a phone call, nothing to acknowledge that his office even read the email much less gave a shit about the problems one of his constituents was having.

    So excuse my own sailoresque language, but Fuck Nelson and the political horse he rode in on. Belsky has my vote.
  • Ray Johnson
    Arthur B, I feel your plight. It is beyond me how so many crimes are completely ignored and not investigated. I know there is a lot of work to do, but you know, it is so sad to see the quality of life disintegrating and law enforcement makes it look like it's the victims who are ridiculous to care.
  • Bill w
    Maybe this will help? - "The festivities will include a DJ, food, rides and amusements, and giveaways"
  • Bill w
    “In Sheepshead Bay, Belsky hopes to rekindle the fight for down-zoning and increased parking. He has already latched onto issues such as the Cherry Hill – Lundy’s debate, in which he skewers the likes of Councilman Nelson, CB 15 Chair Theresa Scavo and State Senator Carl Kruger, for opposing a business that has poured millions into a decrepit building. And he has singled out the fishing fleet as a valuable Brooklyn industry that needs to be promoted by city authorities”.

    This is a dead issue. Business which poured millions into decrepit buildings won. The Special SHB zone was primarily established to promote the fishing fleet by city authorities was trashed and lost. Mr Belsky can’t have it both ways. Either side with the developers because they have the money or stand by rational government planning for the community you would like to live in.
  • I don't see how the two sides are contrary to one another. Cheyy Hill and the fishing fleet could easily co-exist and even create synergy. Imagine if Cherry Hill offered to buy some of the fresh fish people catch?

    Or another example, fishermen can walk in to buy ingredients for use with the fish they just caught.

    The key is putting these ideas in the minds of the consumer and visitors, it requires effort and advertising.

    Anyway, he can support Cherry Hill and the fisherman at the same time with no problem...
  • Bill w
    "Imagine if Cherry Hill offered to buy some of the fresh fish people catch? "
    ILLEGAL

    "fishermen can walk in to buy ingredients for use with the fish they just caught"
    Like they couldn't elsewhere.
  • Ok. Bill, really the attitude is just unnecessary.

    I was just tossing out random ideas on how the two could work together.

    If the local government and the local businesses worked together then I'm sure they could change the law to work some kind of arrangement out no?

    Yes the fisherman could go anywhere to buy their ingredients but again, the point is local synergy. They can catch their fish, run into the fresh market right across the street without moving their car and then go home.

    The key is having everyone work together and find a way to fit everything into one nice little package.

    Too bad everyone has their own agenda.

    Anyway, the point is Supporting Cherry Hill and Supporting the Fishing Fleet are not mutually exclusive. You can have both and can support both.

    If your beef is with supporting developers that want to rush in with their money and wipe everything away, well that's another story. I certainly don't want to see more god damned condos that nobody can afford on the strip.
  • Kreskin
    A prediction. Mr and Mrs belsky will be cruising by August 15th. A little birdie told me that Mr Belsky, who needs 900 signatures to get on the Primary ballot from Democrats who live in his district wasnot able to muster a third of that number. And before you scream about the Election Law, that is nto a technicality....it is a substantive requirement so that only people who can demonstrate a minor amount of support can cost the taxpayers the funds needed for an election and matching funds.

    So bye Bye mr Belsky and your foul mouthed nknow it all manner.
  • All he needs to do is spend a few days outside Sheepshead Bay Train Station with a clip board and he'll get his signatures.
  • clare
    I like Mr. Belsky, man after my own heart and with more energy.
    How can a person using BILL W as a name be so ignorant?
    Oh, maybe it is his name and he's just ignorant.
  • He's got the Liberal line already, so he's not finished even if he loses the Democratic Party primary.

    And getting 900 registered voters to sign a petition is not impossible.

    That said, I'm not that impressed by his projection that he is the outsider running for office. He is a part of the same establishment that backs Mike Nelson. A successful businessman, with a personal interest in development, I can't see him as an alternative candidate.

    It's too bad that Gene Berardelli lives in the wrong part of Sheepshead Bay. I believe that we're on the same page in things that matter greatly to both of us.
  • And one more thing. Ray, you shouldn't have reminded Ned of his temporary lapse of detached journalistic expression. The MTA does that to people, you know.

    And he might win a Pulitzer as a result.
  • Ira Zalcman
    Mr. Belksy is a true American standing up for himself and all us "little guys". He's brave and willing to take on the establishment.
    We need more people like him who are willing to voice the democratic ideal and put his words into action. Bravo to you Mr. Belsky for giving us an election and a choice. You are a real American.
  • Sheila
    Straight to the point --> How many people can actually say they have had more than 2 minute conversation with former Councilman Nelson???? Oddly he is not able to make eye contact and has this strange ramble of a senile man.

    So looky looky here, dried up T Scavs backs down at Uncle Carl's request while Mr. G and pearly gates felt bad about some missing folks.

    Seriously people if you are going to vote either make sure Nelson actually pays you off and then you can go vote for him or give a shit and for God's sake vote for the other guy.
  • Simon L. Belsky
    Lisanne: Hopefully the following will help you understand me a little better.
    1. I am not part of Nelsons establishment since I do not have nor ever sought the backing of any political organization within the district. He owes the political groups. I owe them nothing.
    2. I do not have a personal interest in development? only what is in the best interest of the community as inputed by the people of the community. The Councilman should work for the people, not as Nelson works for Kruger.
    3. I have no political allies and want none unless they share my beliefs as my interests are solely to stop inept management, fraud and corruption in city government and improve the Quality of Life for the District.
    4. I have written that if elected I would give a minimum of 25% of my 1st years salary to senior and after school programs in the district. What has any politician committed to match that.
    5. Gene Berardelli I believe is a good man with integrity that does not exist in the elected officials you have today. I would have enjoyed working with him. I will support Gene over Fidler and have already informed voters in his district of the opportunity for change.
    6. As far as the Liberal Party endorsement, I found out on the internet that they endorsed me. It was someone who was handling my petitioning that contacted them. They endorsed me because I want independent oversight in city government to clean up the inept management, fraud and corruption which is raping the public of billions of dollars.
    7. If you replaced every elected official on election day we could do no worse. Hopefully we would get elected officials that would put the people ahead of their own self interest.
    8. I sued NYC in the NYS Supreme Court and won not to beat a summons, but to show the public that if together we fight for what is right, we can effect change. I will post the Modified Daily News article shortly.
    Instead of assuming things about people that are not true, please ask me direct questions and I will answer them.
    Thanks sincerelyto all the people for your comments regarding support. Evidently you understand what some of my goals were.
    It would be interesting to know the sleazy bird Kreskin is babbling about He might be right but he knows not how dirty his bird may be as the FBI could be looking into the matter. Kreskin, why not give yours and your birds real name. The reporter already apologized for his foul-mouthed comment in the article as being an error and inappropriate, so grow up and be a man, not a parrot.
  • Simon L. Belsky
    What is your Council Member (Nelson) doing for all the people?

    City Council candidate Simon Belsky beats bogus ticket that inspired run
    BY Erin Durkin
    DAILY NEWS STAFF WRITER
    Wednesday, July 8th 2009, 4:00 AM (edited)

    City Council candidate Simon Belsky of Sheepshead Bay holds up the court decision in his case against the city.
    Turns out you can fight City Hall.
    After a 21/2-year battle, a Sheepshead Bay man has won a court ruling throwing out a $115 ticket he received for parking in front of a nonexistent fire hydrant.
    Simon Belsky, 63, was slapped with a ticket in November 2006 for parking in front of a fire hydrant at 2909 Avenue U - even though there's a meter, not a hydrant, located at that address.
    After five administrative challenges to the ticket were ignored or rejected, Belsky sued the city in State Supreme Court last August.
    Last month, Judge Michael Ambrosio ruled the city couldn't prove Belsky broke the rules.
    "The petitioners' claim was entirely persuasive because there is a meter and not a fire hydrant located in front of 2909 Avenue U, the location listed on the summons," Ambrosio wrote.
    He threw out the ticket and awarded Belsky costs and disbursements.
    "I had no doubts I was going to win," Belsky said. "There's no fire hydrant. This is a joke."
    Belsky, a retired businessman who is now running for City Council on a platform touting parking ticket reform, said it wasn't about the money - he kept up the fight out of principle.
    "I don't care about the $115," he said. "How many defective and fraudulently written summonses does the public pay because they cannot afford the time to fight?"
    "The city is screwing the public intentionally for 37 years," he said.
    Glen Bolofsky, who runs a business that helps people fight parking tickets, said the ruling could be good news for drivers facing bogus tickets. But he noted administrative law judges have ignored past rulings that once someone challenges a ticket, it must be dismissed unless the city can prove it is justified.
    "The Supreme court is stating in effect that if the city doesn't have proof, then the respondent - you, me or Mr. Belsky - is innocent until proven guilty," he said. "The city has not yet applied that law."
    The city Department of Finance, which handles parking tickets, did not return calls for comment.

    Note: The Supreme Court has stated/ruled that if your defense statement is “NOT PATENTLY INCREDIBILE” then the burden of proof falls upon the NYC/DOF to prove their case with “SUBSTANTIAL CREDIBLE EVIDENCE”. If they do not then the SUMMONS MUST BE DISMISSED.
    (The city can never prove time difference)

    Simon L. Belsky (Call for HELP!)
    718-769-7406
    Email: parodneydee@gmail.com
    Candidate for City Council District #48
    Brighton Beach, Manhattan Beach, Sheepshead Bay, Madison and Midwood

    Note: This decision could save the people millions of dollars in defective and fraudulently written summonses.

    Vote on September 15th for the only true fighter in the race for City Council not backed by political organizations.

    Simon L. Belsky
  • Mr Belsky: I think it's awesome that you've come here to let us know what your goals are and why you're doing this, however in the future could you refrain from calling anyone "sleazy"?

    You're not representing yourself in the best of light by joining the fray and name calling. Some might call it, creative description, but if you're running for office please please hold yourself above the rest and set an example ok?

    I want to support you, but the minute you decided to run for office you made the choice to be an example for everyone else.

    While I might be able to call anyone on the internet a dirty sleaze bag or any other vernacular you shouldn't.

    I hope you understand the point I'm making.

    Respectfully Yours,
    Arthur Borko
  • Simon L. Belsky
    Mr. Borko: I fully understand the point and agree with your comments. Please understand that in this specific instance I was referring to a bird not an individual. If you would please contact me at my Email address parodneydee@gmail.com for clarification I would sincerely appreciate it. Thank you!
    Simon L. Belsky
  • Mr Belsky: But the "little birdie" he's referring to is a person. He was just trying to be witty with common vernacular. Besides, the person he was referring to was just quoting the law to him, whomever they may be that doesn't make them sleezy.

    Thanks for taking my comment seriously. Though I don't see the point in discussing it in private.

    Speaking of which, do you NEED more signatures? Will you be out and about getting them? If so when? I'll try to stop by to add my signature.
blog comments powered by Disqus